Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Justin's avatar

From the creation account, patriarchy is found to be the natural and “very good” hierarchy that existed prior to the fall. We see this understanding of headship applied in both the Old and New Testament (the whole counsel of God) as good and God-honoring.

Furthermore, this understanding of father-rule symbolizes how Christ redeems and reigns over us. He has called and redeemed a once-rebellious, wayward bride who strives to usurp His authority. He has cleansed her and has now established rightful, loving rule over her (Ephesians 5).

In light of this, it is incorrect to suggest that all patriarchy is tyranny. Husbands and fathers *are* heads. They cannot *not* be heads because headship is integral to the fabric of the covenant relationship as it reflects Christ and the church. They either image Christ well through exercising loving dominion, or they image Christ poorly (lying about Him!) through tyranny or abdication.

No proponent of godly patriarchy here is denying that there are evil patriarchs and that the Lord is opposed to the abuse of women. In the androgynous, egalitarian worldview, the aforementioned hierarchy is dismissed, leaving no room for godly dominion. It calls what God has made to be good “toxic”, encouraging men to abdicate the headship that God has graciously woven into their relationships. A shepherd that abdicates his authority over his flock is a bad shepherd.

Expand full comment
Susan Barackman's avatar

even under godly patriarchy men can be evil- we see the number of sex abuse cases being addressed in many churches today but the so. bapt are making a bigger deal out of woman preachers/pastors than the SA that is widespread. hmmm- a woman preaching christ or a woman being abused vy xcgurch leadership----.gotta get rid of those women pastors !!!!!!

patriarchy is biblical in that is historical, part of the backdrop of the bible but not the point of it---No leadership commands were given to Adam, but both he and Eve were given the same command--- to tend the garden. Patriarchy came in with the fall and Jesus fixed it by his redeeming work on the cross...he broke the patriarchy when he talked with women and they became part of his group and traveled with him.

Both slavery and patriarchy were part of how the Roman world functioned. Paul never talked against either of them. He only told Christians how to operate in a brotherly way if they owned slaves or were slaves. He did the same with patriarchy. The OT gives direction on how to treat slaves. So why do we abhor slavery today and still allow patriarchy?

Under patriarchal, complementarian or egalitarian/mutual teachings a loving christian man will continue to be a loving christian man towards wife, family and others.

Under patriarchal or complementarian an abusive man uses scripture to justify his abuse towards wife, family and others.

Under egalitarian or mutual teachings an abusive man has no excuses ! The door that allows his abuse towards wife family and others is SHUT! Because under that egal teaching both spouses are equal under the headship of Christ and He is the only authority in marriage.

Expand full comment

No posts